On first glance you can see Papa Elias' is not the fanciest place in town but don't let that sway you. The staff is friendly and makes you feel welcome instantly. We came in and checked out the pizza choices and the salad bar and sat down to ...

I read the reviews and I think that sucks that someone would say that about Papa Elias. I was at the parade yesterday in Garden City and we popped in to try them out and we had best service and food. Their chicken tastes even better than ...

THIS IS PAPA ELIAS PIZZA OWNER. A WORKER WAS FIRED AND MADE THREATS TO BRING US DOWN AND THIS IS ONE OF HER WAYS TO DO SO, BY POSTING ALL THESE BAD REVIEWS. PLEASE NEGLECT TO BELIEVE ANYTHING THAT YOU READ UNTIL YOU TRY US FOR YOURSELVES. ...

i'm a regular at papa's and i love it. my family in i go in every tuesday bc i work late on tuesdays and dont like to cook. i had my daughter's first bday party there and becaause papa is so familiar with us he bought her a pretty dress as a ...

The pizza here is pretty much top tier - thin crust, overflowing with sauce cheese and toppings. We were the last ones there for the day and they still gladly made us a pizza (in fact asked us). The real winner, though, is the barbecue chicken. Moist without being greasy, with a sauce that could very well be the best vinegar based sauce i have ever had. The salad bar was good, nothing amazing there, but between the service, the price, and the chicken, easily deserves 5 stars.‎