I had a department meeting and needed something special and boy did NY Pizza come through for me. I ordered two pizza pies and boy they were good. I have been many times and often take out of towners there.

I have to say that I didn't used to be a fan of thin-crust pizza, before eating here. I absolutely love their pizza. I used to go to the other pizza places in Holly Springs, but decided to try this, despite my loathing for anything that has to do with New Yorkers. ;) I am happy I tried it out. I have to say that I have never had a fresh-made pizza there yet. I always get their special-- two slices of pepperoni with a drink... about $6.75 after taxes. I believe they make their special pizzas ahead of time and then throw the two slices in the oven when ordered. The crust is crispy on the bottom, but still pretty floppy. The sauce and the cheese are different than any other around. Great seasoning in the sauce, and the cheese is a bit salty, which I like. The ONLY thing I can say bad about the pepperoni pizza is that it VERY greasy. As soon as I get the slices, I soak up the grease with 3-4 napkins. I don't mind this at all though, because I know it's going to be good! Anyway, we used to go to Homegrown and I've tried La Dolce Vita a few times. Michelangelos is about the closest in style, but I don't like the taste at all.

I am from NY and this is the best pizza I have found since moving here in 2001. The service is great and the pizza is always terrific. The pizza's are huge and the prices are very reasonable compared to the chain pizza shops.

I lived in NY my whole life, and when we came down, we tried about 6,000 pizza places, looking for that NY taste. This place is absolutely the best! The crust is perfect every time, and the ingredients are just heavenly. The people there are nice and the seating area is clean and comfortable. This place is the greatest!