Family Tradition by Chris M. at InsiderPages
My wife's ENTIRE family went to Northwest Missouri State University in Maryville, MO. Pagliai's Pizza was the essential pizza place in our family for literally decades. Whenever we go back for a game we still have to eat there. No other place in town comes close.
Read more at national.citysearch.com
Their garlic bread is the BEST. I love their personal pizzas because they are always the perfect amount.
Their spaghetti is also great. I know it is hard to mess up spaghetti, but theirs is some good stuff. They used to have an all you can eat buffet for spaghetti, but they stopped that a while ago. Sadness.
Be sure to get there early after football games or you'll go hungry. They fill up quick!