I really have only tried their BLT, but I give it 5 stars without a doubt. Get it with the sliced sourdough--heavenly. I signed up on Citysearch just to write this review for this sandwich.
The only bummer is their hours--they are only open mid day during the week. Very nice people work there, mostly people who work closeby go there, but I recommend you go get a sandwich NOW!!! Take it to nearby Tahoe Park (8th ave and 59th St?) to eat it.